I’m divorced and I hate divorce. I know of two clear grounds for biblical divorce: adultery and abandonment. But those are the final stages. What worries me is the expanded range of reasons women have within Christian circles for divorce. Dalrock noted today:
My concern is that the definition of justified divorce has been so expanded as to make a mockery of the concept of marriage. She is also missing a fundamental point; putting on your big girl panties really does lead to happy marriages, at least in the majority of cases. Moreover, if Christians were serious about holding men and women to their vows they would then have the moral authority to try to assist these couples in good faith. While religious leaders may disagree, secular scientists have studied the issue and found that brute force willpower to stay married actually solves surprisingly difficult marital problems. It’s almost as if God designed marriage that way.
The two parts of the definition that are added are abuse and addictions. The trouble is that abuse shades away. There is a difference between someone who is beaten — and I have had friends leave because they arrived at work bruised and battered, and other friends who have managed to work through the violence and strengthen their relationship — and emotional abuse. In addition, addictions has moved from Heroin, methamphetamine and alcohol — which do real damage — to include soft drugs, eating, and unsavoury habits such as watching porn. In fact, the idea of “habits” and “breaking a habit” has disappeared from Christian discussion, when I can remember the idea of instilling Godly habits and removing ungodly habits was actively discussed not even a generation ago.
Part of this seems to be a sense that one must not only be holy (which none of us are) but that one must be seen to be holy. The woman moves to a position outside of scripture of being over-scrupulous. Her hyper religious ideas are intolerable to her husband (who she no longer looks for fulfilment: no man can compete with Jesus and Jesus himself cannot compete with Christian romantic (porn) novels). She is now treating him with contempt.
And in doing that, he withdraws. He will turn to hobbies. He may turn to crutches: over eating, over drinking, the use of pornography (or television, which is basically the same thing nowadays). He is now seen by her to be ungodly, and she has a divorce card.
And as Dalrock says, the sisterhood in the church will support her.
I’m divorced, and I hate divorce. My ex is still a member of the congregation that we used to belong to. I now live in another town.It took me a long, long time to stop feeling condemned by the church or angry with God, to admit my faults, and to return to the church. It is my job at present to heal my children as much as God will allow from the issues relating to the divorce.
We live in a fallen world, where marriages strain, and sometimes break. But that breakage is too common, and the trigger is pulled too fast. Because a divorce hurts everyone as much as any actions that happened in the marriage did. It should be reserved for the most serious situations, and lead to grief not only in the family but also in the church where it happened.
Not celebrated and encouraged. That is part of feminism: it is poisonous and heretical.