Comments on: The Spenglarian Tribal Error [Jer 23]

By: n/u9

Fri, 31 Mar 2017 20:56:40 +0000

I’ve read a few of his columns, I just can’t see buying any of his books. I’ll look around for one — oh, it’s David P. Goldman, not David A.. Also ‘nihil ad hominem’ is ‘nothing against the man’, which is not an error. And referring to David P. Goldman by his pseudonym, without correcting the misdirection, is also an error – and that’s three, not counting ‘nihil ad rem’, which is the real failure of logic in your post, and which is four. Four errors. I do not think I need to ramp up the inventiveness of my insults, but to spare you a moments sympathy, and allow you to reflect on your scattershot thinking.

]]>

By: n/u9

Fri, 31 Mar 2017 08:26:27 +0000

Spengler was not an orthodox jew. You have left the zone known as sane some time ago. Anglos are exactly the people who have instituted what you decry – and forced it on the whole world. Why is it your own medicine tastes so bad? Perhaps try a little of that British imperial propoganda to help it go down.

David A Goldman writes as Spengler. I am referring to his books, which I suggest you read: he states he was orthodox when he wrote them.

On the other issues, you are falling into the error called nihil ad hominem, and you need to ramp up the inventiveness of your insults.

]]>